dark ruling

can necro gardna effect be ativated while Shadow-Imprisoning Mirror is ativated?

no la.

like tat colin, i should had won u at the asian tournament.

yewsoon wrote:

like tat colin, i should had won u at the asian tournament.

lol so long liao still bring up...
Like DS said if u let the turn the mistake is made PASSED, then u shoulden complain liao.

lingbu....i don think that is a complain ....it is more of a response to the answer...sometimes they jus wanna know their deck

But he sounds like he is quite disappointed with the mistaking ruling

actually, the effect CAN be activated.

i agree i think that necro nd to be remove from game is the cost....

then after that the effect go through or not i'm too lazy to check. coz by right, the guardna is not in the grave anymore.

Same logic as activating exiled force when skill drain is on the field.

bahamut84 wrote:

actually, the effect CAN be activated.

ya can be activated cost out, but shadow prison mirror negates the effect of negate atk.

Quote :

ya can be activated cost out, but shadow prison mirror negates the effect of negate atk.

wrong la,dark mirror only negate effect in field/grave,gardna out liao how the mirror negate it

It does seem that Dark Mirror cannot be used to negate Necro Guardna's effect after it is activated because it is out of grave.

Take the example of Cyber Vary. When Light Mirror is on the field, Cyber Vary's 1st effect can still work because removing is a cost and Light Mirror only targets cards on field and in grave. Cyber Vary is now in the remove pile, so its effect activates and will skip opponent's battle phrase this turn.