Ruling on Reborning Synchro monsters

Situation:
Synchro summoned (any synchro monster) successfully. Opponent Book of Moon it. Next turn flipped summoned it but opponent chained Solemn Warning or Solemn Judgment to the flip-summoning. Can i still reborn it back after it is being sent to the grave?

Note that the monster had been successfully summoned before, but was being flipped face down.



Similarly, if it is Chaos Sorcerer instead, can i reborn it back? (i assume the answer would be the same for Chaos Sorcerer and any Synchro monster)

from what i see, u can
this is taken from wikia, might be wrong:
-Synchro Monsters are like Fusion Monsters. Once the Synchro Monster is properly Synchro Summoned, it can be Special Summoned with "Monster Reborn", "Premature Burial", etc. as long as the Synchro Monster is not returned to the Extra Deck. If the Synchro Monster is sent to the Graveyard without being Summoned, such as by the effect of "Gale Dogra", then you cannot Special Summon it.

but from what i know, it was said that as long as a synchro monster is summoned succesfully via sycnhro summon, it can be special summon from grave/ rfg.

this applies to chaos sorc too.

correct me if i m wrong

But the flip summoning after that was negated. de part u mentioned from wikia is about it being summoned successfully and then sent to grave after that. nothing is mentioned about de summoning being negated when it is being flipped summon after it had been successfully summoned before. u get what im trying to highlight right?

i believe that u can still reborn it back.
lets wait for more official support and information ba:)

正規の手順で特殊召喚した特殊召喚モンスターを《月の書》などで裏側守備表示にし、その後破壊されても蘇生制限をクリアでき、蘇生・帰還は可能になる。
（裏側守備表示と反転召喚も参照）
前述のとおり、裏側守備表示にしても「蘇生制限を満たしている」という情報は失われないが、その後《神の宣告》等で反転召喚を無効にされた場合、無効にされた時点で「蘇生制限を満たしている」という情報が失われてしまう。(08/09/05)

Basically, when the synchro is turned facedown, its "successfully summoned" properties is still retained... and when its flipped summoned, the "successfully summoned" properties got negated by solemn warning...

So basically, u cannot reborn a synchro monster that is flipped facedown, then faceup and negated by solemn warning...

pokekid88 wrote:

正規の手順で特殊召喚した特殊召喚モンスターを《月の書》などで裏側守備表示にし、その後破壊されても蘇生制限をクリアでき、蘇生・帰還は可能になる。
（裏側守備表示と反転召喚も参照）
前述のとおり、裏側守備表示にしても「蘇生制限を満たしている」という情報は失われないが、その後《神の宣告》等で反転召喚を無効にされた場合、無効にされた時点で「蘇生制限を満たしている」という情報が失われてしまう。(08/09/05)

Basically, when the synchro is turned facedown, its "successfully summoned" properties has been lost... and when its flipped summoned, the "successfully summoned" properties got negated by solemn warning...

So basically, u cannot reborn a synchro monster that is flipped facedown, then faceup and negated by solemn warning...

This is very clear. As long it's last summoning was negated(I mean only itself sp summon or flipped), u can nv sp summon it back from grave/rfp.

ok. thanks for answering!

Can you special summon red nova dragon or shooting star dragon (synchro-summoned properly)after they were sent to the grave?

Yes. You can.

so also if u synchro summon and was solemn warninged, you cannot special with Monster reborn?

yes because the summoning is negated ...