Q>Starting a chain to set cards, garoth milling effect

Qn1: Is it possible to chain a card to a set card?
E.g.
Player 1: Set a monster
Player 2: Activate Icarus attack straight away.

Qn2: Does Garoth's effect trigger to Celestia mill 4 effect?

To both questions yes

MYultimate wrote:

Qn1: Is it possible to chain a card to a set card?
E.g.
Player 1: Set a monster
Player 2: Activate Icarus attack straight away.

Qn2: Does Garoth's effect trigger to Celestia mill 4 effect?

Qn1:Yes

Qn2: No,because in order to activates garoth's effect it had to be an effect trigger by a lightlord monster but Celestia's effect is a cost by sending cards from deck to the graveyard therefore garoth's effect does not activates... dats what I think

Correct me if I am wrong cause I am not good at rulings too =x

1) no coz setting a monster has no spell speed
2) no coz celestia mill 4 cards is a cost.

Oh kae then sadded =(

bahamut84 wrote:

1) no coz setting a monster has no spell speed.

But you can activate a card in response to the set.

in yugioh there is no such thing as 'in response' lol.

Yes to Question 1. After you set a card, priority will be passed to your opponent. Below is a summary of actions that will result in priority being passed to your opponent.

Giving up of priority:

• After playing a card during the main phase, before the next action:
  
  
  
  • Summon, Flip Summon, Special Summon, Changing of Battle Position of a Monster
    
  • Set a card
    
  • Activate a Speed 1 Spell
    
  
  In the event that the Turn Player continues without voicing out his/her conduct, it is possible to have a rewind when the opponent voices his objection.
  
  
• Declaring the end of various Phase:
  
  
  
  • Draw Phase
    
  • Standby Phase
    
  • Main Phase
    
  • Battle Phase
    
  • End Phase
    
  
  
• Giving up of Priority at various Step:
  
  
  
  • Start Step
    
  • Battle Step
    
  • Damage Step
    
  • End Step
    

Source: 優先権 -遊戯王カードWiki

Question 2 as replied by Baha.

so meaning opponent can CED or icarus after you had set a monster?

i tried it in game, and i can chain to a set monster...

wingwing98 wrote:

so meaning opponent can CED or icarus after you had set a monster?

Please read the first four words of my post:

Akira wrote:

Yes to Question 1.

Is it so hard to understand?

Woot, Akira angry power on.