more rulings to ask ;D

1. if i activate vahala's effect to spc summon a fairy from hand, do i target a fairy in my hand? if yes, do i need to reveal that specific angel first?
=== Ans: no ===

2. if i activate vahala's effect to spc summon a fairy from hand, do i target a fairy in my hand? if yes, can i chain trapdustshoot and return that specific angel back to deck and thus the player loses target?
=== Ans: no ===

3. can i divine warning vahala when it activates it's effect?
=== Ans: no ===

4. if i use test tiger effect to return murmillo to my deck and my opponent chains divine warning, what happens to murmillo and my test tiger
=== Ans: murmillo lives while tiger goes to grave ===

5. if i use murmillo and attack, the attack is successful and i tag a bestiari after battle, can opponent chain an effect veiler?
=== Ans: no ===

6. if my opponent has a caius and forumla, i activate dark hole. he accel into stardust, what happens? will stardust be chain 3 or stardust die w/o being able to use his effect?
=== Ans: stardust just die ===

7. if i have a ladd on my field and my opponent activates vahala, it's effect is negated and it stays as a blank card on the field forever. correct or wrong?

8. if i have a ladd on my field and my opponent activates vahala, it's effect is negated and it stays as a blank card on the field and when ladd is gone, it's effect can be activated again. correct or wrong?

7. if i have a ladd on my field and my opponent activates vahala, it's effect is negated and it is sent to the grave but not considered as destroyed. correct or wrong?

8. if i have no hand cards, i tune out a formulae and draw 1 card, i drew tg werewolf, can i spc summon the werewolf i drew?

9. if i instant fuse, the target was flipped face down by book of moon, does it die during the end phase? [i am asking because i saw a video from duelingdays and they used summoner of illusion to pull out a extrio and it got flipped face down, but end phase it stays on the field. is it that illusion summoner ruling is different from instant fuse?]



hope for any help, thanks guys. don't take me for a retard, i am asking these as people often ask me too. so i want to know how to explain to them, sheesh


`

No you dun have to reveal.
You can chain trapdustshoot.
You can't warning vahalla.
Tribute test tiger chain warning test tiger dies murmillo stay.
Chain formula to dark hole, the synchro monster will die to dark hole.
Battle phase cannot veiler.

1. Nope, you do not have to target or reveal a Fairy in your hand when activating Valhalla's effect. But you do have to have at least one Fairy that can be special summoned from your hand or you cannot activate its effect at all.

2. No, you do not target a Fairy in your hand. When you activate Valhalla's effect to special summon a Fairy and then your opponent sends one of them back to your deck through Trap Dustshoot, you have to summon another Fairy if you have one in your hand.

3. No, because Solemn Warning negates an activation of a Spell card that Special Summons a monster but Valhalla does not Special Summon a monster during its activation. Do not confuse this with Royal Oppression which negates the effect of a card that Special Summons a monster. (In short, Solemn Warning cannot negate Valhalla while Royal Oppression can.)

4. Test Tiger is released as a Cost, so it is sent to the Graveyard. Test Tiger's effect Targets Murmillo first, then Solemn Warning negates the effect of Test Tiger in the Graveyard. (Murmillo is still left on the field)

5. No, because the Tag Out is done during the End of The Battle Phase which is still in the Battle Phase.

6. CL1 Dark Hole, CL2 Formula. Chain Resolves backwards and Stardust is Summoned and then Destroyed by Dark Hole. You cannot interupt during the Chain.

thanks all for the warm responses

lauren

Quote :

No, because Solemn Warning negates an activation of a Spell card that Special Summons a monster but Valhalla does not Special Summon a monster during its activation. Do not confuse this with Royal Oppression which negates the effect of a card that Special Summons a monster. (In short, Solemn Warning cannot negate Valhalla while Royal Oppression can.)

i don't quite get his part though, some of my friends say can. because vahala: you can Special Summon 1 Fairy-Type monster from your hand.

which means if u activate the effect, which is to special summon, so i don't see the logic behind =x

lauren

Quote :

6. CL1 Dark Hole, CL2 Formula. Chain Resolves backwards and Stardust is Summoned and then Destroyed by Dark Hole. You cannot interupt during the Chain.

why cannot interrupt? since stardust is a quick effect. how about another scenario that happened to me recently.

my opponent has a stardust, i mind control him. he chain mst and i pass so mst chain 2, mind control chain 1, he then chain his stardust effect as chain 3. is it correct? if not, why? similar case as the accel synchro =x

curryman wrote:

thanks all for the warm responses

lauren

Quote :

No, because Solemn Warning negates an activation of a Spell card that Special Summons a monster but Valhalla does not Special Summon a monster during its activation. Do not confuse this with Royal Oppression which negates the effect of a card that Special Summons a monster. (In short, Solemn Warning cannot negate Valhalla while Royal Oppression can.)

i don't quite get his part though, some of my friends say can. because vahala: you can Special Summon 1 Fairy-Type monster from your hand.

which means if u activate the effect, which is to special summon, so i don't see the logic behind =x

lauren

Quote :

6. CL1 Dark Hole, CL2 Formula. Chain Resolves backwards and Stardust is Summoned and then Destroyed by Dark Hole. You cannot interupt during the Chain.

why cannot interrupt? since stardust is a quick effect. how about another scenario that happened to me recently.

my opponent has a stardust, i mind control him. he chain mst and i pass so mst chain 2, mind control chain 1, he then chain his stardust effect as chain 3. is it correct? if not, why? similar case as the accel synchro =x

Stardust wasnt summoned when the first card ( Dark hole ) activated.

Dark hole ---> synchro formula + 6 star to stardust --> Dark hole activates its effect before stardust can interrupt.

Mind control --> Cyclone --> You claim nothing to chain --> passed on back to your opponent --> he activates stardust to negate.

The both scenario differ in the 1st sentence, stardust is not on field yet. However the second one stardust was all along on field.

Give you another scenario: Cyclone set card --> call of living dead activates and revives stardust --> Stardust revived but cyclone destroyed it , stardust's effect is not permanent, it loses timing to activate. Stardust goes back to the grave with call of living dead.

So if you are wondering why Jinzo is not destroyed if cyclone destroyed call of living dead that is chained to revive Jinzo, because Jinzo has a permanent effect ( sangan etc).

Hope I can help you here, but if not... you can get another lady to.. if there are? Im not sure too~

curryman wrote:

thanks all for the warm responses


i don't quite get his part though, some of my friends say can. because vahala: you can Special Summon 1 Fairy-Type monster from your hand.

which means if u activate the effect, which is to special summon, so i don't see the logic behind =x

Quote :

Valhalla, Hall of the Fallen, Call of the Mummy, Black Garden, etc... don't "activate" to special summon. It creates a field condition that allows a special summon....

Thats the answer i found for it. It is saying that when you have no monsters on your field, your fulfilled the condition of valhalla and uses its effect to sp. This means there is no activation of valhalla's effect.

and solemn's warning text reads

Quote :

Negate the Summon of a monster OR the activation of a Spell Card, Trap Card, or Effect Monster's effect that includes an effect that Special Summons a monster(s), and destroy that card.

it only negates activation of spell/trap tat special summons monsters
however, for monsters, it negates the effect itself, meaning that activation of the monster's effect is not needed for solemn's warning to negate the monster's special summoning effect

curryman wrote:

why cannot interrupt? since stardust is a quick effect. how about another scenario that happened to me recently.

my opponent has a stardust, i mind control him. he chain mst and i pass so mst chain 2, mind control chain 1, he then chain his stardust effect as chain 3. is it correct? if not, why? similar case as the accel synchro =x

For your original question, darkhole was activated before stardust was on the field. So when the chain resolves, stardust is summoned, darkhole resolves(already activated).
stardust effect text:

Quote :

You can Tribute this card to negate the activation of a Spell Card, Trap Card, or Effect Monster's effect that destroys a card(s) on the field, and destroy that card.

For your new scenario, stardust was on the field during the activation of MST, therefore he can respond to the MST before the chain resolves

just remember this very simple ruling for yu-gi-oh

You cannot add in a new chain until u fully resolve the current one.

lingbu wrote:

curryman wrote:

thanks all for the warm responses

lauren

Quote :

No, because Solemn Warning negates an activation of a Spell card that Special Summons a monster but Valhalla does not Special Summon a monster during its activation. Do not confuse this with Royal Oppression which negates the effect of a card that Special Summons a monster. (In short, Solemn Warning cannot negate Valhalla while Royal Oppression can.)

i don't quite get his part though, some of my friends say can. because vahala: you can Special Summon 1 Fairy-Type monster from your hand.

which means if u activate the effect, which is to special summon, so i don't see the logic behind =x

lauren

Quote :

6. CL1 Dark Hole, CL2 Formula. Chain Resolves backwards and Stardust is Summoned and then Destroyed by Dark Hole. You cannot interupt during the Chain.

why cannot interrupt? since stardust is a quick effect. how about another scenario that happened to me recently.

my opponent has a stardust, i mind control him. he chain mst and i pass so mst chain 2, mind control chain 1, he then chain his stardust effect as chain 3. is it correct? if not, why? similar case as the accel synchro =x

Stardust wasnt summoned when the first card ( Dark hole ) activated.

Dark hole ---> synchro formula + 6 star to stardust --> Dark hole activates its effect before stardust can interrupt.

Mind control --> Cyclone --> You claim nothing to chain --> passed on back to your opponent --> he activates stardust to negate.

The both scenario differ in the 1st sentence, stardust is not on field yet. However the second one stardust was all along on field.

Give you another scenario: Cyclone set card --> call of living dead activates and revives stardust --> Stardust revived but cyclone destroyed it , stardust's effect is not permanent, it loses timing to activate. Stardust goes back to the grave with call of living dead.

So if you are wondering why Jinzo is not destroyed if cyclone destroyed call of living dead that is chained to revive Jinzo, because Jinzo has a permanent effect ( sangan etc).

Hope I can help you here, but if not... you can get another lady to.. if there are? Im not sure too~

hmmm, i understand now what what's with the last sentence? lol

bryan

Quote :

and solemn's warning text reads

Quote:
Negate the Summon of a monster OR the activation of a Spell Card, Trap Card, or Effect Monster's effect that includes an effect that Special Summons a monster(s), and destroy that card.

i understand the part of creating a field condition but the text says negate the summon of a monster OR the activation of a spell card that includes an effect that Special Summons a monster(s). the sentence says that it can destroy a card which includes an effect to spc summon. am i wrong?

curryman wrote:

bryan

Quote :

and solemn's warning text reads

Quote:
Negate the Summon of a monster OR the activation of a Spell Card, Trap Card, or Effect Monster's effect that includes an effect that Special Summons a monster(s), and destroy that card.

i understand the part of creating a field condition but the text says negate the summon of a monster OR the activation of a spell card that includes an effect that Special Summons a monster(s). the sentence says that it can destroy a card which includes an effect to spc summon. am i wrong?

Quote :

card's activation is defined as casting from ONLY hand OR from set position on the spell/trap zone

activating a card's effect can be done anywhere.

addon: Therefore, for spell and trap, the activation that allows to sp must be negated upon being used from hand / facedown on M/T zone. If it is already face-up, thus activation of the card is already done, you cannot solomn warning it

Activating a spell/trap card is not equal to activating the effect of a spell/trap.

Activating Valhalla (the card) does not result in a special summon, so you cannot warning.

Activating Valhalla (the effect) cannot be warning because you are not activating the card.

Just compare the text with Oppression.

=============================

Quote :

the sentence says that it can destroy a card which includes an effect to spc summon

Please dont ever use the above sentence as an example again.

I've had crazy people arguing as they use Solemn Warning on a Gale when the effect that halves is activated because the card includes an effect to special summon.

L-O-L. All kinds of crazy people in the world. >_>

Ball-Snow wrote:

curryman wrote:

bryan

Quote :

and solemn's warning text reads

Quote:
Negate the Summon of a monster OR the activation of a Spell Card, Trap Card, or Effect Monster's effect that includes an effect that Special Summons a monster(s), and destroy that card.

i understand the part of creating a field condition but the text says negate the summon of a monster OR the activation of a spell card that includes an effect that Special Summons a monster(s). the sentence says that it can destroy a card which includes an effect to spc summon. am i wrong?

Quote :

card's activation is defined as casting from ONLY hand OR from set position on the spell/trap zone

activating a card's effect can be done anywhere.

addon: Therefore, for spell and trap, the activation that allows to sp must be negated upon being used from hand / facedown on M/T zone. If it is already face-up, thus activation of the card is already done, you cannot solomn warning it

ok liao, i finally understand from ur last statement. it clears up everything. thx =D

bahamut84 wrote:

Activating a spell/trap card is not equal to activating the effect of a spell/trap.

Activating Valhalla (the card) does not result in a special summon, so you cannot warning.

Activating Valhalla (the effect) cannot be warning because you are not activating the card.

Just compare the text with Oppression.

=============================

Quote :

the sentence says that it can destroy a card which includes an effect to spc summon

Please dont ever use the above sentence as an example again.

I've had crazy people arguing as they use Solemn Warning on a Gale when the effect that halves is activated because the card includes an effect to special summon.

i understand but i just want to know the way to explain to people as there's a lot of debate on it. i have more crazy people coming up with crazy rulings. hope you can kindly help. that would be good. thx baha =D

shaunewbiez wrote:

L-O-L. All kinds of crazy people in the world. >_>

agree, most of the rulings i ask were stuffs done by other people. i have more crazy rulings above, do take a look ^^

No. 7 - 9 Vahalla is sent to the Graveyard and not considered as destroyed.

bishzor101 wrote:

No. 7 - 9 Vahalla is sent to the Graveyard and not considered as destroyed.

ok, thanks for the reply : )

8. if i have no hand cards, i tune out a formulae and draw 1 card, i drew tg werewolf, can i spc summon the werewolf i drew?

Yes.

9. if i instant fuse, the target was flipped face down by book of moon, does it die during the end phase? [i am asking because i saw a video from duelingdays and they used summoner of illusion to pull out a extrio and it got flipped face down, but end phase it stays on the field. is it that illusion summoner ruling is different from instant fuse?]

Monster is refreshed but not counted as fusioned, so you can't revive if it goes to grave.
think rescue cat, one is affected by book of moon, the other dies instead of the moon affected.

If you are wondering what is refreshed.. I have nothing to say.

8. if i have no hand cards, i tune out a formulae and draw 1 card, i drew tg werewolf, can i spc summon the werewolf i drew?

No because its a different timing.

bahamut84 wrote:

8. if i have no hand cards, i tune out a formulae and draw 1 card, i drew tg werewolf, can i spc summon the werewolf i drew?

No because its a different timing.

thx baha.

7. if i have a ladd on my field and my opponent activates vahala, it's effect is negated and it stays as a blank card on the field forever. correct or wrong?

wrong all the continuous spell/trap/field magic/equip magic will get sent to grave

9. if i instant fuse, the target was flipped face down by book of moon, does it die during the end phase? [i am asking because i saw a video from duelingdays and they used summoner of illusion to pull out a extrio and it got flipped face down, but end phase it stays on the field. is it that illusion summoner ruling is different from instant fuse?]

no it doesnt die.

hamtaro wrote:

7. if i have a ladd on my field and my opponent activates vahala, it's effect is negated and it stays as a blank card on the field forever. correct or wrong?

wrong all the continuous spell/trap/field magic/equip magic will get sent to grave

9. if i instant fuse, the target was flipped face down by book of moon, does it die during the end phase? [i am asking because i saw a video from duelingdays and they used summoner of illusion to pull out a extrio and it got flipped face down, but end phase it stays on the field. is it that illusion summoner ruling is different from instant fuse?]

no it doesnt die.

ty : )

8. No. Because by the time you draw the card, it would have meant that the summon was successful and has fully resolved. This would mean that the TG Werewolf that you drew no longer has something to chain to and has missed its timing. Therefore, it cannot be SP'ed