accel synchro: black rose and stardust

Scenario 1:

Player A controls a magic android, formulae synchron and caius.
Player B summons dark arm and declares piority to destroy android.
Player A accel synchro formulae with caius to stardust dragon and tries to negate dark arm's effect.

Question: Is player A correct?

Scenario 2:

Player A controls a magic android, formulae synchron and caius.
Player B summons dark arm and declares piority to destroy caius.
Player A accel synchro formulae with android to blackrose dragon and tries to activate effect.

Question: Is player A correct?

curryman wrote:

Scenario 1:

Player A controls a magic android, formulae synchron and caius.
Player B summons dark arm and declares piority to destroy android.
Player A accel synchro formulae with caius to stardust dragon and tries to negate dark arm's effect.

Question: Is player A correct?

When both players passed consecutively to allow the Chain to resolve, it will resolve in one-shot. Nothing can be added to the Chain while it is still resolving.

Chain 1: Dark Armed Dragon's effect
Chain 2: Formula Synchron's effect

Resolving, Forumla Synchron will bring out Stardust Dragon. The Chain is not yet empty and still resolving, hence no effects (i.e. Stardust Dragon's) can be activated. Dark Armed Dragon's effect will then resolve, only to resolve with no effect (missing target) destroying Caius.

curryman wrote:

Scenario 2:

Player A controls a magic android, formulae synchron and caius.
Player B summons dark arm and declares piority to destroy caius.
Player A accel synchro formulae with android to blackrose dragon and tries to activate effect.

Question: Is player A correct?

Similar to the above, except that Optional Trigger Effects (i.e. Black Rose Dragon's first effect) will miss its timing to activate if the effect is triggered in the middle of a Chain. Reasoning is as above.

Akira wrote:

curryman wrote:

Scenario 1:

Player A controls a magic android, formulae synchron and caius.
Player B summons dark arm and declares piority to destroy android.
Player A accel synchro formulae with caius to stardust dragon and tries to negate dark arm's effect.

Question: Is player A correct?

When both players passed consecutively to allow the Chain to resolve, it will resolve in one-shot. Nothing can be added to the Chain while it is still resolving.

Chain 1: Dark Armed Dragon's effect
Chain 2: Formula Synchron's effect

Resolving, Forumla Synchron will bring out Stardust Dragon. The Chain is not yet empty and still resolving, hence no effects (i.e. Stardust Dragon's) can be activated. Dark Armed Dragon's effect will then resolve, only to resolve with no effect (missing target) destroying Caius.

curryman wrote:

Scenario 2:

Player A controls a magic android, formulae synchron and caius.
Player B summons dark arm and declares piority to destroy caius.
Player A accel synchro formulae with android to blackrose dragon and tries to activate effect.

Question: Is player A correct?

Similar to the above, except that Optional Trigger Effects (i.e. Black Rose Dragon's first effect) will miss its timing to activate if the effect is triggered in the middle of a Chain. Reasoning is as above.

ok i get it, i was thinking the same as you. thx for clearing the doubt so ppl can learn too : )